[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":543},["ShallowReactive",2],{"navigation_docs":3,"-delivery-program-manager-plus-plus-ci-triage":234,"-delivery-program-manager-plus-plus-ci-triage-surround":538},[4,26,47,68,89,114,135,164,181,210],{"title":5,"path":6,"stem":7,"children":8,"page":25},"1. Getting Started & Pricing","\u002Fgetting-started","01.getting-started",[9,13,17,21],{"title":10,"path":11,"stem":12},"1.1 5-Minute Quickstart","\u002Fgetting-started\u002Fquickstart","01.getting-started\u002F1.quickstart",{"title":14,"path":15,"stem":16},"1.2 Project Boards Setup","\u002Fgetting-started\u002Fboard-init","01.getting-started\u002F2.board-init",{"title":18,"path":19,"stem":20},"1.3 GitHub Actions & GitLab CI Runner Setup","\u002Fgetting-started\u002Fci-runners","01.getting-started\u002F3.ci-runners",{"title":22,"path":23,"stem":24},"1.4 Organization Credit Pool & Per-Function Credit Pricing","\u002Fgetting-started\u002Forg-credits-and-slack","01.getting-started\u002F4.org-credits-and-slack",false,{"title":27,"path":28,"stem":29,"children":30,"page":25},"2. Pair & Triad Programming","\u002Fpair-and-triad-programming","02.pair-and-triad-programming",[31,35,39,43],{"title":32,"path":33,"stem":34},"2.1 Cross-Model Pair & Triad Programming","\u002Fpair-and-triad-programming\u002Foverview","02.pair-and-triad-programming\u002F1.overview",{"title":36,"path":37,"stem":38},"2.2 Isolated Shadow Workspaces","\u002Fpair-and-triad-programming\u002Fshadow-jj-workspaces","02.pair-and-triad-programming\u002F2.shadow-jj-workspaces",{"title":40,"path":41,"stem":42},"2.3 Cryptographic File-Scope Leases & Small-Diff Gates","\u002Fpair-and-triad-programming\u002Ffile-scope-leases","02.pair-and-triad-programming\u002F3.file-scope-leases",{"title":44,"path":45,"stem":46},"2.4 Sub-Issue to Subagent Fan-Out & Delta Velocity","\u002Fpair-and-triad-programming\u002Fsub-issue-fanout","02.pair-and-triad-programming\u002F4.sub-issue-fanout",{"title":48,"path":49,"stem":50,"children":51,"page":25},"3. Declarative Workflow Policy","\u002Fworkflow-policy","03.workflow-policy",[52,56,60,64],{"title":53,"path":54,"stem":55},"3.1 Declarative Workflow Policy Schema","\u002Fworkflow-policy\u002Fschema-reference","03.workflow-policy\u002F1.schema-reference",{"title":57,"path":58,"stem":59},"3.2 Cryptographic Conformance Matrix & Memory Tombstones","\u002Fworkflow-policy\u002Fwp-01-to-wp-15-matrix","03.workflow-policy\u002F2.wp-01-to-wp-15-matrix",{"title":61,"path":62,"stem":63},"3.3 Two-Tier Organization Governance Lattice","\u002Fworkflow-policy\u002Forg-policy-floor","03.workflow-policy\u002F3.org-policy-floor",{"title":65,"path":66,"stem":67},"3.4 Trusted Handoff Hooks & Independent Verification","\u002Fworkflow-policy\u002Fhandoff-hooks-h1-to-h5","03.workflow-policy\u002F4.handoff-hooks-h1-to-h5",{"title":69,"path":70,"stem":71,"children":72,"page":25},"4. Visual Geometry & Copy Gates","\u002Fvisual-and-copy-tribunals","04.visual-and-copy-tribunals",[73,77,81,85],{"title":74,"path":75,"stem":76},"12-Tuple DOM Geometry (176\u002F176)","\u002Fvisual-and-copy-tribunals\u002Fui-gate-geometry","04.visual-and-copy-tribunals\u002F1.ui-gate-geometry",{"title":78,"path":79,"stem":80},"Vision-3 Geometry & Auto-Patch","\u002Fvisual-and-copy-tribunals\u002Fcross-model-design-tribunal","04.visual-and-copy-tribunals\u002F2.cross-model-design-tribunal",{"title":82,"path":83,"stem":84},"64\u002F64 Declaration Copy Gate","\u002Fvisual-and-copy-tribunals\u002Fdeclaration-copy-gate","04.visual-and-copy-tribunals\u002F3.declaration-copy-gate",{"title":86,"path":87,"stem":88},"Synthetic CI Canary","\u002Fvisual-and-copy-tribunals\u002Fsynthetic-ci-canary","04.visual-and-copy-tribunals\u002F4.synthetic-ci-canary",{"title":90,"path":91,"stem":92,"children":93,"page":25},"5. Autonomous AI Program Manager","\u002Fdelivery-program-manager","05.delivery-program-manager",[94,98,102,106,110],{"title":95,"path":96,"stem":97},"Overview: Dual-Brain AI PM","\u002Fdelivery-program-manager\u002Foverview","05.delivery-program-manager\u002F1.overview",{"title":99,"path":100,"stem":101},"Executable Tickets & Auto-Splitting","\u002Fdelivery-program-manager\u002Fchinwag-tasks-and-never-stop","05.delivery-program-manager\u002F2.chinwag-tasks-and-never-stop",{"title":103,"path":104,"stem":105},".codegraph & FinOps Routing","\u002Fdelivery-program-manager\u002Fcodegraph-and-finops-arbitrage","05.delivery-program-manager\u002F3.codegraph-and-finops-arbitrage",{"title":107,"path":108,"stem":109},"++ Triage & CI Recovery","\u002Fdelivery-program-manager\u002Fplus-plus-ci-triage","05.delivery-program-manager\u002F4.plus-plus-ci-triage",{"title":111,"path":112,"stem":113},"Flight Deck & Trajectory Time-Travel","\u002Fdelivery-program-manager\u002Fflight-deck-and-time-travel","05.delivery-program-manager\u002F5.flight-deck-and-time-travel",{"title":115,"path":116,"stem":117,"children":118,"page":25},"6. The Chinwag Way & Scrimmages","\u002Fthe-chinwag-way","06.the-chinwag-way",[119,123,127,131],{"title":120,"path":121,"stem":122},"Academic Foundations","\u002Fthe-chinwag-way\u002Facademic-foundations","06.the-chinwag-way\u002F1.academic-foundations",{"title":124,"path":125,"stem":126},"Chips (◈) & 7-Day Survival","\u002Fthe-chinwag-way\u002Fchips-and-7day-survival","06.the-chinwag-way\u002F2.chips-and-7day-survival",{"title":128,"path":129,"stem":130},"Sealed Card (.cwcard.png) Drills","\u002Fthe-chinwag-way\u002Fsealed-card-handoff-drills","06.the-chinwag-way\u002F3.sealed-card-handoff-drills",{"title":132,"path":133,"stem":134},"Calibration Scrimmages","\u002Fthe-chinwag-way\u002Fcalibration-scrimmages","06.the-chinwag-way\u002F4.calibration-scrimmages",{"title":136,"path":137,"stem":138,"children":139,"page":25},"7. Zero-Knowledge Cryptography","\u002Fzero-knowledge-cryptography","07.zero-knowledge-cryptography",[140,144,148,152,156,160],{"title":141,"path":142,"stem":143},"PQ-HPKE Wire Envelope","\u002Fzero-knowledge-cryptography\u002Fpq-hpke-envelope","07.zero-knowledge-cryptography\u002F1.pq-hpke-envelope",{"title":145,"path":146,"stem":147},"Verify-Before-Decrypt (K1+K2)","\u002Fzero-knowledge-cryptography\u002Fverify-before-decrypt","07.zero-knowledge-cryptography\u002F2.verify-before-decrypt",{"title":149,"path":150,"stem":151},"Blinded Commitments & 128B Flywheel","\u002Fzero-knowledge-cryptography\u002Fblind-commitments","07.zero-knowledge-cryptography\u002F3.blind-commitments",{"title":153,"path":154,"stem":155},"Local Viewer & CISO DPA","\u002Fzero-knowledge-cryptography\u002Flocal-viewer-and-dpa","07.zero-knowledge-cryptography\u002F4.local-viewer-and-dpa",{"title":157,"path":158,"stem":159},"A.509 Agent Passports","\u002Fzero-knowledge-cryptography\u002Fa509-agent-pkix","07.zero-knowledge-cryptography\u002F5.a509-agent-pkix",{"title":161,"path":162,"stem":163},"chinwag-acu & CISO Kill Switch","\u002Fzero-knowledge-cryptography\u002Fchinwag-acu","07.zero-knowledge-cryptography\u002F6.chinwag-acu",{"title":165,"path":166,"stem":167,"children":168,"page":25},"8. E2EE Mesh & Extension SDK","\u002Fmesh-and-extensions","08.mesh-and-extensions",[169,173,177],{"title":170,"path":171,"stem":172},"chinwag-mesh & 3-Repo Time Machine","\u002Fmesh-and-extensions\u002Fsdk-and-cwcard-png-transport","08.mesh-and-extensions\u002F1.sdk-and-cwcard-png-transport",{"title":174,"path":175,"stem":176},"warroom & whisper Extensions","\u002Fmesh-and-extensions\u002Fwarroom-and-whisper","08.mesh-and-extensions\u002F2.warroom-and-whisper",{"title":178,"path":179,"stem":180},"teleport, shroud & vault","\u002Fmesh-and-extensions\u002Fgit-bundle-and-vault","08.mesh-and-extensions\u002F3.git-bundle-and-vault",{"title":182,"path":183,"stem":184,"children":185,"page":25},"9. CLI & GraphQL Reference","\u002Fcli-and-graphql-reference","09.cli-and-graphql-reference",[186,190,194,198,202,206],{"title":187,"path":188,"stem":189},"chinwag tasks & task","\u002Fcli-and-graphql-reference\u002Fchinwag-task","09.cli-and-graphql-reference\u002F1.chinwag-task",{"title":191,"path":192,"stem":193},"chinwag board & GraphQL","\u002Fcli-and-graphql-reference\u002Fchinwag-board","09.cli-and-graphql-reference\u002F2.chinwag-board",{"title":195,"path":196,"stem":197},"chinwag pair & triad","\u002Fcli-and-graphql-reference\u002Fchinwag-pair-and-triad","09.cli-and-graphql-reference\u002F3.chinwag-pair-and-triad",{"title":199,"path":200,"stem":201},"chinwag bus","\u002Fcli-and-graphql-reference\u002Fchinwag-bus","09.cli-and-graphql-reference\u002F4.chinwag-bus",{"title":203,"path":204,"stem":205},"chinwag-ci, fork-run & ui-gate","\u002Fcli-and-graphql-reference\u002Fchinwag-ci-and-uigate","09.cli-and-graphql-reference\u002F5.chinwag-ci-and-uigate",{"title":207,"path":208,"stem":209},"chinwag memory & tombstone","\u002Fcli-and-graphql-reference\u002Fchinwag-memory","09.cli-and-graphql-reference\u002F6.chinwag-memory",{"title":211,"path":212,"stem":213,"children":214,"page":-1},"10. Architecture PRDs","\u002Fprds","10.prds",[215,218,222,226,230],{"title":216,"path":212,"stem":217},"10.0 Ratified Architecture PRDs","10.prds\u002Findex",{"title":219,"path":220,"stem":221},"10.1 Ephemeral Tart Cleanroom VMs & Declarative Nix","\u002Fprds\u002Ftart-cleanroom-vms","10.prds\u002F1.tart-cleanroom-vms",{"title":223,"path":224,"stem":225},"10.2 Executable Delivery Boards & Proof-of-Green","\u002Fprds\u002Fdelivery-executable-boards","10.prds\u002F2.delivery-executable-boards",{"title":227,"path":228,"stem":229},"10.3 Cursor Agent SDK Importer & Sanitizer","\u002Fprds\u002Fcursor-agent-sdk-importer","10.prds\u002F3.cursor-agent-sdk-importer",{"title":231,"path":232,"stem":233},"10.4 Chinwag Local Web App & Command Center","\u002Fprds\u002Fhuman-command-center-ui","10.prds\u002F4.human-command-center-ui",{"id":235,"title":236,"body":237,"command":250,"description":531,"extension":532,"links":533,"meta":534,"navigation":535,"path":108,"seo":536,"stem":109,"__hash__":537},"docs\u002F05.delivery-program-manager\u002F4.plus-plus-ci-triage.md","5.4 Sub-20ms CI Routing & Escalation Triage",{"type":238,"value":239,"toc":522},"minimark",[240,244,251,263,281,284,289,299,301,316,319,326,359,361,377,384,396,436,469,475,477,488,495,518],[241,242,236],"h1",{"id":243},"_54-sub-20ms-ci-routing-escalation-triage",[245,246,247],"p",{},[248,249,250],"code",{},"chinwag-ci triage --coalesce-window 1400ms",[245,252,253,254,257,258,262],{},"In a standard GitHub Actions or GitLab CI workflow, a failed build sits idle in a web tab until a developer notices the red ",[248,255,256],{},"✗",", clicks through 4,000 lines of raw logs, copies the stack trace, and pastes it back into their IDE chat window. That human copy-paste loop costs ",[259,260,261],"strong",{},"25 to 45 minutes per broken build",".",[245,264,265,268,269,272,273,276,277,280],{},[248,266,267],{},"chinwag ci-report"," replaces that manual loop with a two-tier automated recovery protocol driven by Chinwag Reflex-1 (",[248,270,271],{},"50 Cr"," wakeup & fix cycle) and Chinwag Delivery-2 (",[248,274,275],{},"100 Cr"," ",[248,278,279],{},"++ Triage"," + Pair escalation).",[282,283],"hr",{},[285,286,288],"h2",{"id":287},"the-two-tier-strike-recovery-protocol","The Two-Tier Strike Recovery Protocol",[290,291,297],"pre",{"className":292,"code":294,"language":295,"meta":296},[293],"language-text","CI Runner Fails (cargo test \u002F pnpm build \u002F pytest)\n  │\n  ▼\nchinwag ci-report extracts failing span + commit hash + active task lease\n  │\n  ├──► STRIKE 1 (First failure on this task lease):\n  │      Chinwag Reflex-1 (\u003C20ms routing · 50 Cr wakeup & fix cycle)\n  │      Routes structured error span directly into the active coding agent's\n  │      Shadow jj workspace inbox. Agent patches and re-verifies locally.\n  │\n  └──► STRIKE >= 2 (Repeated failure or cross-module regression):\n         Chinwag Delivery-2 \"++ Triage\" Escalation (100 Cr)\n         1. Queries Negative Memory Tombstones (chinwag memory recall)\n         2. Cross-checks .codegraph upstream commits that landed concurrently\n         3. Synthesizes a root-cause recovery plan + pairs a second model family\n","text","",[248,298,294],{"__ignoreMap":296},[282,300],{},[285,302,304,305,308,309,311,312,315],{"id":303},"strike-1-direct-20ms-agent-routing-fix-cycle-50-cr-032-on-growth-pack","Strike 1: Direct ",[248,306,307],{},"\u003C20ms"," Agent Routing & Fix Cycle (",[248,310,271],{}," · ",[248,313,314],{},"$0.32"," on Growth Pack)",[245,317,318],{},"82% of CI failures are simple first-strike issues: a missing feature flag in a Cargo workspace build, a snapshot mismatch, or a platform-specific import path.",[245,320,321,322,325],{},"On ",[259,323,324],{},"Strike 1",", Chinwag Reflex-1 does not waste time spinning up a heavy planning session:",[327,328,329,337,344],"ol",{},[330,331,332,333,336],"li",{},"It strips noisy container setup logs and isolates the exact compiler\u002Ftest failure span (",[248,334,335],{},"\u003C= 64 lines",").",[330,338,339,340,343],{},"It verifies the active ",[248,341,342],{},"\u003CSEAT>#\u003CINSTANCE>"," lease holder for the branch.",[330,345,346,347,350,351,356,357,336],{},"It delivers a signed ",[248,348,349],{},"CiFailureEnvelopeV1"," directly to that agent thread in ",[259,352,353],{},[248,354,355],{},"\u003C 20ms"," and completes the wakeup and verified patch cycle (",[248,358,271],{},[282,360],{},[285,362,364,365,368,369,371,372,311,374,315],{"id":363},"strike-2-triage-root-cause-escalation-100-cr-064-on-growth-pack","Strike ",[248,366,367],{},">= 2",": ",[248,370,279],{}," Root-Cause Escalation (",[248,373,275],{},[248,375,376],{},"$0.64",[245,378,379,380,383],{},"When the same task fails CI twice in a row (",[259,381,382],{},"Strike 2","), letting the same coding agent retry the same approach in a loop wastes tokens and CI minutes.",[245,385,386,387,395],{},"Chinwag Delivery-2 automatically triggers ",[259,388,389,391,392,394],{},[248,390,279],{}," (Chinwag Delivery-2 · ",[248,393,275],{},")",":",[327,397,398,408,422],{},[330,399,400,403,404,407],{},[259,401,402],{},"Negative Memory Tombstone Lookup:"," Checks whether the agent is attempting an approach that was previously killed and tombstoned (",[248,405,406],{},"chinwag memory tombstone",") in this repository.",[330,409,410,413,414,417,418,421],{},[259,411,412],{},"Concurrent Commit Diffing:"," Inspects ",[248,415,416],{},".codegraph"," to see if another branch merged a breaking trait or schema change into ",[248,419,420],{},"main"," while this task was in flight.",[330,423,424,427,428,431,432,435],{},[259,425,426],{},"Structured Recovery Plan & Re-Pairing:"," Emits a signed ",[248,429,430],{},"PlusPlusTriagePlanV1"," that either rebases the ",[248,433,434],{},"Shadow jj"," workspace cleanly or attaches an independent reviewer model from a different model family to break the reasoning deadlock.",[290,437,441],{"className":438,"code":439,"language":440,"meta":296,"style":296},"language-bash shiki shiki-themes material-theme-lighter material-theme material-theme-palenight","# Trigger or inspect a ++ Triage recovery plan manually from the CLI\nchinwag ci-report --inspect-last --triage\n","bash",[248,442,443,452],{"__ignoreMap":296},[444,445,448],"span",{"class":446,"line":447},"line",1,[444,449,451],{"class":450},"sHwdD","# Trigger or inspect a ++ Triage recovery plan manually from the CLI\n",[444,453,455,459,463,466],{"class":446,"line":454},2,[444,456,458],{"class":457},"sBMFI","chinwag",[444,460,462],{"class":461},"sfazB"," ci-report",[444,464,465],{"class":461}," --inspect-last",[444,467,468],{"class":461}," --triage\n",[290,470,473],{"className":471,"code":472,"language":295,"meta":296},[293],"[++ TRIAGE · Strike 2] Task: TASK-204 (Branch: cw\u002Ftask-204-webhook-ed25519)\n  • Root Cause Identified: Upstream commit 8a3f11c changed `WebhookPayload::raw_bytes()`\n    to return ` &[u8]` instead of `Bytes` in `crates\u002Fwebhook-types`.\n  • Tombstone Match: tombstone-webhook-copy-alloc-v1 (\"Never clone webhook body prior to Ed25519 verify\")\n  • Prescribed Fix: Rebase Shadow jj workspace onto 8a3f11c and pass slice reference directly to `verifying_key.verify_strict()`.\n  • Dispatched To: @RUST#7f9a2c11e04b8821a930d4e11022bc04 (1.38s · 100 Cr)\n",[248,474,472],{"__ignoreMap":296},[282,476],{},[285,478,480,481,484,485,487],{"id":479},"next-section-the-chinwag-way-mo-grpo-chips-20ms-drills","Next Section: The Chinwag Way (",[248,482,483],{},"MO-GRPO"," Chips & ",[248,486,307],{}," Drills)",[245,489,490,491,494],{},"Explore the peer-reviewed engineering research behind Chinwag's multi-agent coordination, 7-day code survival scoring (",[248,492,493],{},"SURV","), and 4-minute calibration drills.",[496,497,498,507],"ul",{},[330,499,500,276,503],{},[259,501,502],{},"Next:",[504,505,506],"a",{"href":121},"Academic Foundations of The Chinwag Way",[330,508,509,276,512],{},[259,510,511],{},"Ready to eliminate the 40-minute broken-build tax?",[504,513,517],{"href":514,"rel":515},"https:\u002F\u002Fchinwag.sh\u002Fpricing",[516],"nofollow","Reserve Your Organization Credit Pack →",[519,520,521],"style",{},"html pre.shiki code .sHwdD, html code.shiki .sHwdD{--shiki-light:#90A4AE;--shiki-light-font-style:italic;--shiki-default:#546E7A;--shiki-default-font-style:italic;--shiki-dark:#676E95;--shiki-dark-font-style:italic}html pre.shiki code .sBMFI, html code.shiki .sBMFI{--shiki-light:#E2931D;--shiki-default:#FFCB6B;--shiki-dark:#FFCB6B}html pre.shiki code .sfazB, html code.shiki .sfazB{--shiki-light:#91B859;--shiki-default:#C3E88D;--shiki-dark:#C3E88D}html .light .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-light);background: var(--shiki-light-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-light-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-light-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-light-text-decoration);}html.light .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-light);background: var(--shiki-light-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-light-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-light-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-light-text-decoration);}html .default .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-default);background: var(--shiki-default-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-default-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-default-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-default-text-decoration);}html .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-default);background: var(--shiki-default-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-default-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-default-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-default-text-decoration);}html .dark .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-dark);background: var(--shiki-dark-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-dark-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-dark-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-dark-text-decoration);}html.dark .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-dark);background: var(--shiki-dark-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-dark-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-dark-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-dark-text-decoration);}",{"title":296,"searchDepth":454,"depth":454,"links":523},[524,525,527,529],{"id":287,"depth":454,"text":288},{"id":303,"depth":454,"text":526},"Strike 1: Direct \u003C20ms Agent Routing & Fix Cycle (50 Cr · $0.32 on Growth Pack)",{"id":363,"depth":454,"text":528},"Strike >= 2: ++ Triage Root-Cause Escalation (100 Cr · $0.64 on Growth Pack)",{"id":479,"depth":454,"text":530},"Next Section: The Chinwag Way (MO-GRPO Chips & \u003C20ms Drills)","How chinwag ci-report eliminates the 40-minute broken-build tax with Strike-1 direct routing & fix cycle (50 Cr) and Strike >= 2 ++ Triage root-cause synthesis & Pair re-assignment (100 Cr).","md",null,{},{"title":107},{"title":236,"description":531},"wymfnkiigw8wmkFVpansWAEndK7zog-klSAPd1e-OLg",[539,541],{"title":103,"path":104,"stem":105,"description":540,"children":-1},"How DELIVERY uses local structural call graphs (.codegraph) to prevent cross-module breakage and optimize multi-model inference costs.",{"title":111,"path":112,"stem":113,"description":542,"children":-1},"Branch failed agent runs in 0ms with 0 replayed tokens via chinwag fork-run and Shadow-KV (250 Credits), pinpoint exact trajectory divergence with Weighted-LCS chinwag diff-run, and freeze failures into \u003C50ms offline CI cassettes with chinwag tombstone --emit-test.",1794371826571]